Parties and Attorneys
Liebovich et al. v. Tobin et al.
Division 2
Division 2
Case Number B306184
| Party | Attorney |
|---|---|
| Matthew Liebovich : Petitioner and Appellant | Mitchell Keiter Keiter Appellate Law The Beverly Hills Law Building 424 South Beverly Drive Beverly Hills, CA 90212 |
| Joshua Liebovich : Petitioner and Appellant | Mitchell Keiter Keiter Appellate Law The Beverly Hills Law Building 424 South Beverly Drive Beverly Hills, CA 90212 |
| Andrew Liebovich : Petitioner and Appellant | Mitchell Keiter Keiter Appellate Law The Beverly Hills Law Building 424 South Beverly Drive Beverly Hills, CA 90212 |
| Esther Liebovich : Petitioner and Appellant | Mitchell Keiter Keiter Appellate Law The Beverly Hills Law Building 424 South Beverly Drive Beverly Hills, CA 90212 |
| Diane Janice Tobin : Respondent | Robert Neil Sacks Sacks, Glazier, Franklin & Lodise LLP 350 South Grand Avenue Suite 500 Los Angeles, CA 90071-3475 Douglas E. Lawson Sacks Glazier 350 S Grand Ave Ste 3500 Los Angeles, CA 90071 Christopher D. Carico Carico Macdonald Kil & Benz LLP 841 Apollo St. Suite 450 El Segundo, CA 90245-4722 John Andrew Scheerer Sacks, Glazier, Franklin & Lodise LLP 350 S Grand Ave Ste 3500 Los Angeles, CA 90071-3475 |
| Lori Robin : Respondent | Robert Neil Sacks Sacks, Glazier, Franklin & Lodise LLP 350 South Grand Avenue Suite 500 Los Angeles, CA 90071-3475 Christopher D. Carico Carico Macdonald Kil & Benz LLP 841 Apollo St. Suite 450 El Segundo, CA 90245-4722 Douglas E. Lawson Sacks Glazier 350 S Grand Ave Ste 3500 Los Angeles, CA 90071 John Andrew Scheerer Sacks, Glazier, Franklin & Lodise LLP 350 S Grand Ave Ste 3500 Los Angeles, CA 90071-3475 |
| Marc Chopp : Respondent | Robert Neil Sacks Sacks, Glazier, Franklin & Lodise LLP 350 South Grand Avenue Suite 500 Los Angeles, CA 90071-3475 Christopher D. Carico Carico Macdonald Kil & Benz LLP 841 Apollo St. Suite 450 El Segundo, CA 90245-4722 Douglas E. Lawson Sacks Glazier 350 S Grand Ave Ste 3500 Los Angeles, CA 90071 John Andrew Scheerer Sacks, Glazier, Franklin & Lodise LLP 350 S Grand Ave Ste 3500 Los Angeles, CA 90071-3475 |
Case Summary
Trial Court Case:
BP138119
Court of Appeal Case:
B306184
Supreme Court Case:
S271214
Caution: For information on when opinions may be cited or relied upon, click here .
Division:
2
Case Caption:
Liebovich et al. v. Tobin et al.
Case Type:
CV
Filing Date:
05/28/2020
Completion Date:
11/15/2021
Oral Argument Date/Time:
08/19/2021 12:45 PM
Docket (Register of Actions)
Liebovich et al. v. Tobin et al.
Division 2
Division 2
Case Number B306184
| Date | Description | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 06/04/2020 | Notice of appeal lodged/received. | Notice of appeal filed on May 28, 2020 by Matthew Liebovich, Joshua Liebovich, Andrew Liebovich, Esther Liebovich |
| 06/04/2020 | Default notice sent-appellant notified per rule 8.100(c). | No Fee Received for Notice of Appeal filed on May 28, 2020 |
| 06/16/2020 | Filing fee. | $775 Filing Fee |
| 06/22/2020 | Civil case information statement filed. | Petitioner and Appellant: Matthew Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter |
| 07/02/2020 | Notice per rule 8.124 - with reporter's transcript. | Appellant filed July 2, 2020: Appendix w.RTNOTE: appellant incorporates by reference the record in prior appeal in case B292177 |
| 07/06/2020 | Motion to dismiss filed (before record). | Respondent's motion to dismiss untimely appeal |
| 07/20/2020 | Opposition filed. | appellants' opposition to motion to dismiss appeal |
| 07/20/2020 | Order filed. | The court has read and considered respondents' motion to dismiss the untimely appeal filed on July 6, 2020, and the opposition filed by appellants on July 20, 2020. Respondents' motion to dismiss the appeal is denied. The Superior Court clerk's notice of the minute order entered on December 18, 2019 (Exhibit B to the motion) was not sufficient to trigger the time for filing a notice of appeal under California Rules of Court, Rule 8.104(a)(1)(A). The notice was not a separate document, but was page five of the minute order that did not bear the title of a "Notice of Entry" on the first page. (See Sunset Millenium Associates, LLC v. Le Songe, LLC (2006 138 Cal.App.4th 256, 259-261.) Accordingly, Appellants had 180 days from entry of the order to appeal, and their notice of appeal filed May 28, 2020, was timely. IT IS ORDERED. |
| 09/08/2020 | Reporter's transcript filed. | R-1 |
| 10/09/2020 | Received document entitled: | service copy of email from Attorney Mitchell Keiter requesting electronic copy of RT (from court reporter) |
| 10/19/2020 | Requested - extension of time | |
| 10/20/2020 | Granted - extension of time. | |
| 12/18/2020 | Requested - extension of time | |
| 12/21/2020 | Granted - extension of time. | No further extension of time will be granted. |
| 01/14/2021 | Requested - extension of time | |
| 01/14/2021 | Granted - extension of time. | Final Extension |
| 02/11/2021 | Appellant notified re failure to timely file opening brief. | an AOB/appendix was due by 1/28/21 |
| 02/26/2021 | Appellant's appendix filed. | Volume 1 of 1 |
| 02/26/2021 | Appellant's opening brief. | Petitioner and Appellant: Matthew Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter Petitioner and Appellant: Joshua Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter Petitioner and Appellant: Esther Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter Three extensions granted for a total of 101 days: |
| 03/03/2021 | Errata filed to: | appellant's notice of errata re opening brief |
| 03/22/2021 | Stipulation of extension of time filed to: | |
| 03/24/2021 | Returned document for non-conformance. | Respondents' stipulation for an extension of time rejected via TrueFiling. Filing submitted under wrong case number (B306183). |
| 04/19/2021 | Respondent's appendix filed. | 1 volume |
| 04/19/2021 | Respondent's brief. | Respondent: Diane Janice Tobin Attorney: Douglas E. Lawson Respondent: Lori Robin Attorney: Douglas E. Lawson Respondent: Marc Chopp Attorney: Douglas E. Lawson One extension granted for a total of 30 days: |
| 05/05/2021 | Requested - extension of time | |
| 05/06/2021 | Granted - extension of time. | |
| 05/26/2021 | Requested - extension of time | |
| 05/26/2021 | Granted - extension of time. | |
| 06/08/2021 | Appellant's reply brief. | Petitioner and Appellant: Esther Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter Two extensions granted for a total of 29 days: |
| 06/09/2021 | Case fully briefed. | |
| 07/15/2021 | Calendar notice sent electronically. Calendar date: | Thursday, August 19, 2021 at 12:45pm via Blue Jeans Video Conference |
| 07/20/2021 | Request for oral argument filed by: | John A. Sheerer, respondent's counsel - argue, 10 minutes. |
| 07/22/2021 | Request for oral argument filed by: | Mitchell Keiter, appellant's counsel - argue, 30 minutes. |
| 08/16/2021 | Filed letter from: | letter from respondent's counsel informing the court that appellant Joshua Liebovich recently died; |
| 08/18/2021 | Filed letter from: | Mitchell Keiter, counsel for appellant- the passing of appellant has no effect on the legal issues. Will proceed with OA |
| 08/19/2021 | Cause argued and submitted. | 1:22:05 - 1:46:24 |
| 08/26/2021 | Opinion filed. | (Signed Unpublished) 21p./AFF/HLCThe order is affirmed. The trustees are entitled to their costs on appeal. |
| 09/10/2021 | Rehearing petition filed. | appellants' petition for rehearing |
| 09/13/2021 | Petition for rehearing denied. | |
| 10/05/2021 | Service copy of petition for review received. | |
| 10/07/2021 | Record transmitted to Supreme Court electronically. | |
| 10/12/2021 | Service copy of petition for review received. | S271214- Answer to petition for review |
| 11/10/2021 | Petition for review denied in Supreme Court. | The petition for review is denied. [S271214] |
| 11/15/2021 | Remittitur issued. | The trustees are entitled to their costs on appeal. |
| 11/15/2021 | Case complete. | |
| 02/14/2022 | Received document entitled: | notice from U.S. Supreme Court re petition for writ of certiorari was filed 2/8/22 - docket no. 21-1116. |
| 04/22/2022 | Received letter from: | Supreme Court re: order denying petition for writ of certiorari is denied |
Briefs
Liebovich et al. v. Tobin et al.
Division 2
Division 2
Case Number B306184
| Brief | Due Date | Date Filed | Party and Attorney | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Civil case information statement filed. | 06/22/2020 | Petitioner and Appellant: Matthew Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter | | |
| Appellant's opening brief. | 02/26/2021 | Petitioner and Appellant: Matthew Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter Petitioner and Appellant: Joshua Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter Petitioner and Appellant: Esther Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter | Three extensions granted for a total of 101 days: | |
| Respondent's brief. | 04/19/2021 | Respondent: Diane Janice Tobin Attorney: Douglas E. Lawson Respondent: Lori Robin Attorney: Douglas E. Lawson Respondent: Marc Chopp Attorney: Douglas E. Lawson | One extension granted for a total of 30 days: | |
| Appellant's reply brief. | 06/08/2021 | Petitioner and Appellant: Esther Liebovich Attorney: Mitchell Keiter | Two extensions granted for a total of 29 days: |
Future Scheduled Actions
Liebovich et al. v. Tobin et al.
Division 2
Division 2
Case Number B306184
No information found.
Disposition
Liebovich et al. v. Tobin et al.
Division 2
Division 2
Case Number B306184
Description:
Affirmed in full
Date:
08/26/2021
Disposition Type:
Final
21p./AFF/HLC
21p./AFF/HLC
Publication Status:
Signed Unpublished
Author:
Hoffstadt, Brian M.
Participants:
Lui, Elwood (Concur)
Chavez, Victoria M. (Concur)
Chavez, Victoria M. (Concur)
Case Citation:
none
Trial Court
Liebovich et al. v. Tobin et al.
Division 2
Division 2
Case Number B306184
Trial Court Name:
Los Angeles County Superior Court
County:
Los Angeles
Trial Court Case Number:
BP138119
Trial Court Judge:
Johnson, Barbara
Trial Court Judgment Date:
12/18/2019