Log In
judyrecords
search tips
700 million+
United States Court Cases

California Fourth Appellate District Division 3 Record

Brantner v. The Superior Court of Orange County

Parties and Attorneys

Brantner v. The Superior Court of Orange County
Case Number G057022
Party Attorney
Mark Brantner : Petitioner
Elizabeth R. Gropman
Leonard Carder LLP
1330 Broadway Ste 1450
Oakland, CA 94612

The Superior Court of Orange County : Respondent
Hon. David R. Chaffee Dept. C20
700 Civic Center Drive West
Santa Ana, CA 92701

Verify, Inc. : Real Party in Interest
Sean Min Kim
Ogletree, Deakins, Nash, Smoak & Stewart, P.C.
695 Town Center Drive
Fifteenth Floor
Costa Mesa, CA 92626



Case Summary

Trial Court Case:
30-2018-01025128
Court of Appeal Case:
G057022
Division:
Case Caption:
Brantner v. The Superior Court of Orange County
Case Type:
CV
Filing Date:
11/13/2018
Completion Date:
02/13/2019
Oral Argument Date/Time:


Docket (Register of Actions)

Brantner v. The Superior Court of Orange County
Case Number G057022
Date Description Notes
11/13/2018 Filed petition for writ of: By pet Mark Brantner.
11/28/2018 Opposition requested. Petitioner filed a petition for a writ of mandate on November 13, 2018. Real party in interest is invited to file a preliminary opposition or other informal response within six days of the date of this order. No fee is required for this response invited by this court.
12/05/2018 Note: Real party of interest did not file a preliminary opposition or other informal response.
12/11/2018 Alternative writ or OSC issued. THE COURT:*
On November 13, 2018, petitioner filed a petition for writ of mandate. The petition challenged respondent court's November 2, 2018 order denying petitioner's Code of Civil Procedure section 170.6 peremptory challenge. The petition contends petitioner timely filed his peremptory challenge on October 30, 2018, within 15 days after the October 15, 2018 notice of the assignment of the judge for all purposes.
GOOD CAUSE APPEARING, respondent court is hereby ordered to:
(1) set aside and vacate its November 2, 2018 order denying the peremptory challenge as untimely, and enter a new and different order granting the peremptory challenge;

Or, in the alternative,
(2) SHOW CAUSE before this court, at a date and time to be designated by this court, why a peremptory writ of mandate should not issue.
If respondent court is considering compliance with alternative (1) above, it should provide notice and an opportunity to be heard to the parties before changing its order. (See Brown, Winfield & Canzoneri, Inc. v. Superior Court (2010) 47 Cal.4th 1233.) If respondent court chooses to comply with alternative (1) above, it shall notify this court within 60 days of the date of this order, and provide a copy of its order complying with the directives in alternative (1). If respondent court chooses not to comply with alternative (1), this court will issue an order specifying the briefing schedule for the return and reply.
01/10/2019 Received copy of: Superior Court minute orders dated 01/04/19 and 12/13/18. Superior Court granted plaintiff's 170.6 challenge.
01/14/2019 Petition denied or dismissed after alternative writ or palma issued. This court issued an alternative writ on December 11, 2018, directing the superior court to set aside and vacate its November 2, 2018 order denying petitioner's Code of Civil Procedure section 170.6 peremptory challenge and to enter a new and different order granting the peremptory challenge.

On January 10, 2019, this court received notice that on January 4, 2019, having heard from the parties, the superior court granted petitioner's Code of Civil Procedure section 170.6 peremptory challenge, complying with the alternative writ.

Accordingly, the alternative writ issued by this court on December 11, 2018 is DISCHARGED. The petition for writ of mandate is DISMISSED as moot.

Moore/Ikola/Thompson
02/13/2019 Remittitur issued.
02/13/2019 Case complete.
05/17/2021 Record shipped to records center All documents are scanned.


Briefs

Brantner v. The Superior Court of Orange County
Case Number G057022

No information found.



Future Scheduled Actions

Brantner v. The Superior Court of Orange County
Case Number G057022

No information found.



Disposition

Brantner v. The Superior Court of Orange County
Case Number G057022
Description:
Petition denied or dismissed after alternative writ or palma issued.
Date:
01/14/2019
Disposition Type:
Final
Publication Status:
Author:
Participants:
Case Citation:
none


Trial Court

Brantner v. The Superior Court of Orange County
Case Number G057022
Trial Court Name:
Orange County Superior Court - Main
County:
Orange
Trial Court Case Number:
30-2018-01025128
Trial Court Judge:
Chaffee, David
Trial Court Judgment Date: