Case Heading (06-74) | |||||
Case Number: | 06-74 | Case Docketed On: | 04/06/2006 | ||
Linked To: | 06-75 | ||||
Status: | Closed | ||||
Original Court: | First Judicial District Laramie County | Case Type: | Direct Appeal - Civil - Education (Title 21) | ||
Short Title: | CAMPBELL COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT, STATE OF WYOMING, et al., LARAMIE COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. ONE, et al.; WYOMING EDUCATION ASSOCIATION; WYOMING SCHOOL BOARD ASSOCIATION, BIG HORN COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. ONE, et al. v. THE STATE OF WYOMING | ||||
Full Title: | CAMPBELL COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT, STATE OF WYOMING, et al., Appellants (Plaintiffs), LARAMIE COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. ONE, et al.; WYOMING EDUCATION ASSOCIATION; WYOMING SCHOOL BOARD ASSOCIATION Appellants (intervening Plaintiffs), BIG HORN COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. ONE, et al., Appellants (Plaintiffs), v. THE STATE OF WYOMING, Appellee (Defendant). |
- Party Information |
Role | Party Name | Attorney(s) |
Appellant | Campbell County School District | Ford T. Bussart Marvin L. Tyler |
Appellant | Laramie County School District No. 1 | Paul J. Hickey Richard D. Bush |
Appellant | Wyoming Education Association | Patrick E. Hacker Gregory Patrick Hacker Erin Maureen Kendall |
Appellant | Wyoming School Board Association | Tracy J. Copenhaver |
Appellant | Big Horn County School District No. 1 | Timothy J. Kirven Benjamin Scott Kirven |
Appellant | Teton County School District No. 1 | Sara E. Van Genderen |
Appellant | Natrona School District No. 1 | Kathleen Baker Dixon Stefanie Lee Boster |
Appellee | The State of Wyoming | Michael R. O'Donnell Rhonda Sigrist Woodard |
- Case Decision Information | |
Issues: | Schools |
Opinion Number: | 2008 WY 2 |
Citation: |
Docketing Filter View |
Display: |
Docket Information | |||||
Filing Date | Document Description | Docket Entry Type | Docket Entry Subtype | Status | |
04/06/2006 | Event - Docketed and indexed | Event | Docketed and indexed | Final | |
04/06/2006 | Notice-Incoming - Record completion notice from district court | Notice-Incoming | Record completion notice from district court | Final | |
04/06/2006 | Fees - Docket fee received | Fees | Docket fee received | Final | |
04/06/2006 | Notice-Outgoing - Docketing letter | Notice-Outgoing | Docketing letter | Final | |
04/24/2006 | Notice-Incoming - Designation of record. Joinder of appellant Teton County School District No. 1 in the designation of record on appeal of appellant Laramie County School District No. 1. | Notice-Incoming | Designation of record | Final | |
05/17/2006 | Brief - Appellant, Wyoming School Board Association; and received copy of designation of record on appeal 5/24/06. | Brief | Appellant | Final | |
05/23/2006 | Brief - Appellants. Campbell County School District, Sweetwater County School District Number One, Sweetwater County School District Number Two, and Uinta County School District Number One; and received copy of designation of record on appeal. | Brief | Appellant | Final | |
05/23/2006 | Brief - Appellant Big Horn County School District Number One, et al.; and received copy of brief on cd rom. | Brief | Appellant | Final | |
05/23/2006 | Brief - Appellant Wyoming Education Association. | Brief | Appellant | Final | |
05/24/2006 | Notice-Incoming - Statement of costs. Wyoming School Boards Association. | Notice-Incoming | Statement of costs | Final | |
05/24/2006 | Brief - Appellant Teton County School District No. 1; and received copy of brief on disk on 6/7/06. | Brief | Appellant | Final | |
05/24/2006 | Notice-Incoming - Statement of costs. Joinder of appellant Teton County School District No. 1 in the statement of costs of appellant Campbell County School District No. 1, et al. | Notice-Incoming | Statement of costs | Final | |
05/24/2006 | Brief - Appellant, Laramie County School District No. One; received copy of brief on disk; and received copy of designation of record on appeal. | Brief | Appellant | Final | |
05/24/2006 | Motion - Oral argument - exceed time limit; and received proposed order. | Motion | Oral argument - exceed time limit | Final | |
05/24/2006 | Brief - Appellant (Intervening Plaintiff) Natrona County School District Number One; and received copy of designation of record on 5/25/06. | Brief | Appellant | Final | |
05/26/2006 | Notice-Internal - Recusal memo. Justice Burke recused. | Notice-Internal | Recusal memo | Final | |
05/26/2006 | Notice-Internal - Recusal memo. Chief Justice Hill recused. | Notice-Internal | Recusal memo | Final | |
05/30/2006 | Motion - Consolidate. State's motion to consolidate its appellee brief(s) and obtain an exception to rule 7.06, Wyoming Rules of Appellate Procedure. | Motion | Consolidate | Final | |
05/30/2006 | Order - Grant. Order granting motion requesting exception to W.R.A.P. 1.01(c) | Order | Grant | Final | |
06/01/2006 | Response/Objection - Motion. State of Wyoming's response to appellants' motion to enlkarge time for oral argument. | Response/Objection | Motion | Final | |
06/02/2006 | Order - Assignment of judge. Chief Justice Hill and Justice Burke recused and assigning District Judge Jeffrey A. Donnell and District Judge Norman E. Young to act in this matter. | Order | Assignment of judge/justice | Final | |
06/02/2006 | Order - Assignment of judge. Chief Justice Hill and Justice Burke recused and assigning District Judge Jeffrey A. Donnell and District Judge Norman E. Young to act in this matter. | Order | Assignment of judge/justice | Final | |
06/05/2006 | Motion - Admission pro hac vice. Motion pro hac vice and entry of appearance as local counsel. | Motion | Admission pro hac vice | Final | |
06/05/2006 | Motion - Amicus - leave to participate. Motion to file brief as amici curiae; and received proposed brief of amici curiae. (Northern Arapaho Tribe and Wyoming Parent Teacher Association) | Motion | Amicus - leave to participate | Final | |
06/06/2006 | Order - Grant. Order granting motion to enlarge time for oral argument. (two hours total) | Order | Grant | Final | |
06/09/2006 | Response/Objection - Motion. Challengers' response to state's motion to consolidate appellee briefs and obtain an exception to rule 7.06, Wyoming Rules of Appellate Procedure. | Response/Objection | Motion | Final | |
06/09/2006 | Response/Objection - Motion. State of Wyoming's response to motion to file brief as amici curiae. | Response/Objection | Motion | Final | |
06/10/2006 | Notice-Incoming - Change of address. (Kathleen B. Dixon) | Notice-Incoming | Change of address | Final | |
06/12/2006 | Notice-Incoming - Other. Amended certificate of service for the State of Wyoming's response to motion to file brief as amici curiae. | Notice-Incoming | Other | Final | |
06/15/2006 | Order - Grant. Order granting motion to consolidate appellee briefs (and extend filing time by 30 days). | Order | Grant | Final | |
06/15/2006 | Order - Amicus - deny participation. Order denying leave to file brief of amicus curiae. | Order | Amicus - deny participation | Final | |
06/23/2006 | Motion - Clarification. State's motion for clarification of stay. | Motion | Clarification | Final | |
07/10/2006 | Response/Objection - Motion. Response of WSBA, Campbell County School District, Sweetwater County School District No. 1, Sweetwater County School District No. 2, and Uinta County School District No. 1, to state's motion for clarification of stay. | Response/Objection | Motion | Final | |
07/11/2006 | Response/Objection - Reply. State's reply to response regarding motion for clarification of stay. | Response/Objection | Reply | Final | |
07/18/2006 | Order - Granting motion to clarify stay. | Order | Grant | Final | |
08/10/2006 | Brief - Appellee, State of Wyoming; received copy of brief on flash drive; and received certification of no additional designation of the record for transmission to the Wyoming Supreme Court. | Brief | Appellee | Final | |
08/21/2006 | Notice-Incoming - Change of address (Stefanie L. Boster) | Notice-Incoming | Change of address | Final | |
08/28/2006 | Notice-Outgoing - Request for transmitted record on appeal | Notice-Outgoing | Request for transmitted record on appeal | Final | |
09/06/2006 | Record - Transmitted record on appeal, sixty-four volumes. Volumes I-XVIII, original papers; volume XIX, second amended final exhibit list; volumes XX-XXXIV, transcripts; volumes XXXV-XXXI, exhibits; volume XXXII, original Supreme Court record from first appeal; volumes XXXXIII-XXXXVII, original Supreme Court record from second appeal; volumes XXXXVIII-LXIV, transcripts, dispositions and exhibits from original first and second appeals to Supreme Court. *NOTE: designated index dated August 31, 2006 does not match original index dated March 31, 2006 as pleadings are in different volumes than cited on briefs. Per Chief Justice Voigt, the record is not to be returned to Clerk of District Court for correction. | Record | Transmitted record on appeal | Final | |
09/12/2006 | Notice-Outgoing - Transmitted record on appeal filed | Notice-Outgoing | Transmitted record on appeal filed | Final | |
10/08/2006 | Event - Oral argument presented. Argued before Chief Justice Voigt, Justices Golden and Kite, and DJJ's Donnell and Young (Tracy J. Copenhaver, Richard D. Bush, Sara E. Van Genderen, Kathleen B. Dixon, Ford T. Bussart, Marvin L. Tyler, Patrick E. Hacker, Gregory P. Hacker, and Timothy J. Kirven, arguments by Messrs. Bush, Copenhaver, Bussart, Kirven, and P. Hacker for appellants in Case No. 06-74; Michael R. O'Donnell, State's Counsel and Rhonda Sigrist Woodard, Special Assistant Attorney General, argument by Mr. O'Donnell and Ms. Woodard for appellees in Case No. 06-74) and taken under advisement. | Event | Oral argument presented | Final | |
10/08/2006 | Notice-Internal - Oral argument notice. | Notice-Internal | Oral argument notice | Final | |
12/11/2006 | Notice-Incoming - Additional authority | Notice-Incoming | Additional authority | Final | |
06/13/2007 | Notice-Incoming - Additional authority. Second notice of supplemental authorities. | Notice-Incoming | Additional authority | Final | |
06/22/2007 | Notice-Incoming - Additional authority (response to State's notice) | Notice-Incoming | Additional authority | Final | |
01/08/2008 | Opinion - Opinion and journal order affirming in part and reversing in part. Justice Kite writing for the court. | Opinion | Opinion and journal order | Final | |
01/24/2008 | Notice-Outgoing - Mandate | Notice-Outgoing | Mandate | Final | |
01/24/2008 | Record - Record returned to district court. Arrangements made by Hickey & Evans, LLP to transport record back to the First Judicial District Court by Interstate Moving. | Record | Record returned to district court | Final | |
01/24/2008 | Notice-Outgoing - Record return letter | Notice-Outgoing | Record return letter | Final | |
01/24/2008 | Event - Case closed | Event | Case closed | Final | |
01/31/2008 | Notice-Incoming - Other. Record return receipt. Record signed for 1/25/08 by First Judicial Clerk of District Court. Record (40 boxes) transported by Interstate Moving. | Notice-Incoming | Other | Final |