Case Heading (S-08-0162) | |||||
Case Number: | S-08-0162 | Case Docketed On: | 07/31/2008 | ||
Linked To: | S-08-0161 | ||||
Status: | Closed | ||||
Original Court: | First Judicial District Laramie County | Case Type: | Direct Appeal - Civil - Water (Title 41) | ||
Short Title: | PENNACO ENERGY INC. and DEVON ENERGY PRODUCTION COMPANY, L.P. v. WILLIAM F. WEST RANCH, LLC, L.J. TURNER, KAREN TURNER, WENDY TURNER, JENNIFER TURNER, and MICHAEL TURNER and PATRICK TYRRELL, WYOMING STATE ENGINEER and THE WYOMING BOARD OF CONTROL | ||||
Full Title: | PENNACO ENERGY INC. and DEVON ENERGY PRODUCTION COMPANY, L.P., Appellants (Intervenors/Defendants), v. WILLIAM F. WEST RANCH, LLC, L.J. TURNER, KAREN TURNER, WENDY TURNER, JENNIFER TURNER, and MICHAEL TURNER, Appellees (Plaintiffs) and PATRICK TYRRELL, WYOMING STATE ENGINEER and THE WYOMING BOARD OF CONTROL, Appellees (Defendants). |
- Party Information |
Role | Party Name | Attorney(s) |
Appellant | Pennaco Energy, Inc. | Brent R. Kunz John C. Martin Lucas Evan Buckley |
Appellant | Devon Energy Production Company, L.P. | Scott P. Klosterman Margo Harlan Sabec |
Appellee | William F. West Ranch, LLC | Catherine M. Fox Jon Mark Stewart Sarah Ann Klahn |
Appellee | L.J. Turner | Catherine M. Fox Jon Mark Stewart Sarah Ann Klahn |
Appellee | Karen Turner | Catherine M. Fox Jon Mark Stewart Sarah Ann Klahn |
Appellee | Wendy Turner | Catherine M. Fox Jon Mark Stewart Sarah Ann Klahn |
Appellee | Jennifer Turner | Catherine M. Fox Jon Mark Stewart Sarah Ann Klahn |
Appellee | Michael Turner | Catherine M. Fox Jon Mark Stewart Sarah Ann Klahn |
Appellee | State Engineer's Office - State Engineer | Bruce A. Salzburg Jay Arthur Jerde Peter K. Michael Marion Jane Yoder |
Appellee | State Engineer's Office - Board of Control Division | Bruce A. Salzburg Jay Arthur Jerde Peter K. Michael Marion Jane Yoder |
- Case Decision Information | |
Issues: | Administrative Law and Procedure, Jurisdiction, Water Law |
Opinion Number: | 2009 WY 62 |
Citation: |
Docketing Filter View |
Display: |
Docket Information | |||||
Filing Date | Document Description | Docket Entry Type | Docket Entry Subtype | Status | |
07/31/2008 | Event - Docketed and indexed | Event | Docketed and indexed | Final | |
07/31/2008 | Notice-Incoming - Record completion notice from district court | Notice-Incoming | Record completion notice from district court | Final | |
07/31/2008 | Fees - Docket fee received | Fees | Docket fee received | Final | |
07/31/2008 | Notice-Outgoing - Docketing letter | Notice-Outgoing | Docketing letter | Final | |
08/04/2008 | Motion - Dismiss - involuntary | Motion | Dismiss - involuntary | Final | |
08/04/2008 | Event - Hardcopy received - Appellees-Plaintiffs' motion and memorandum to dismiss appeal of Pennaco Energy, Inc. and Devon Energy Production Company, L.P. | Event | Hardcopy received | Final | |
08/15/2008 | Response/Objection - Motion | Response/Objection | Motion | Final | |
08/15/2008 | Event - Hardcopy received memorandum in opposition to motion to dismiss | Event | Hardcopy received | Final | |
08/26/2008 | Order - Denying motion to dismiss appeal | Order | Deny | Final | |
09/04/2008 | Motion - Consolidate | Motion | Consolidate | Final | |
09/04/2008 | Event - Hardcopy received | Event | Hardcopy received | Final | |
09/17/2008 | Brief - Appellant | Brief | Appellant | Final | |
09/17/2008 | Event - Hardcopy received | Event | Hardcopy received | Final | |
09/17/2008 | Response/Objection - Motion | Response/Objection | Motion | Final | |
09/17/2008 | Event - Hardcopy received - opposition to motion to consolidate | Event | Hardcopy received | Final | |
09/24/2008 | Order - Consolidating cases and granting, in part, request to participate. | Order | Consolidating cases | Final | |
11/03/2008 | Brief - Appellee | Brief | Appellee | Final | |
11/03/2008 | Event - Hardcopy received - brief of appellee - Initial brief of William F. West Ranch, LLC, L.J. Turner, Karen Turner, Wendy Turner, Jennifer Turner and Michael Turner | Event | Hardcopy received | Final | |
11/05/2008 | Brief - Failure to file - appellee State | Brief | Failure to file - appellee | Final | |
11/14/2008 | Order - Oral argument scheduled | Order | Oral argument scheduled | Final | |
11/19/2008 | Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting - Marion Yoder for appellees State Engineer and Board of Control | Notice-Incoming | Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting | Final | |
11/19/2008 | Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting - Scott P. Klosterman for appellants. | Notice-Incoming | Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting | Final | |
11/21/2008 | Event - Hardcopy received - Reply Brief of Appellants Pennaco Energy Inc. and Devon Energy Production Company, L.P. | Event | Hardcopy received | Final | |
11/21/2008 | Brief - Appellant reply | Brief | Appellant reply | Final | |
11/24/2008 | Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting - Kate Fox for West and Turner. | Notice-Incoming | Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting | Final | |
11/24/2008 | Notice-Outgoing - Request for transmitted record on appeal from District Court Clerk | Notice-Outgoing | Request for transmitted record on appeal | Final | |
11/26/2008 | Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting - John Martin for appellants. | Notice-Incoming | Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting | Final | |
12/03/2008 | Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting - Sarah Klahn for West and Turners. | Notice-Incoming | Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting | Final | |
12/05/2008 | Record - Transmitted record on appeal from district court, five volumes. Volumes I-IV, original papers; Volume V, transcript. | Record | Transmitted record on appeal | Final | |
12/05/2008 | Notice-Outgoing - Transmitted record on appeal filed | Notice-Outgoing | Transmitted record on appeal filed | Final | |
12/18/2008 | Event - Oral argument presented. Argued before full Court (Catherine M. Fox, J. Mark Stewart, argument by Ms. Fox for appellants; Marion Jane Yoder, Peter K. Michael, argument by Ms. Yoder for appellees; John C. Martin, Scott P. Klosterman, argument by Mr. Martin for S-08-0162 appellants) and taken under advisement. | Event | Oral argument presented | Final | |
12/18/2008 | Notice-Internal - Oral argument notice | Notice-Internal | Oral argument notice | Final | |
05/07/2009 | Opinion - Opinion and journal order affirming, Justice Kite writing for the Court | Opinion | Opinion and journal order | Final | |
05/26/2009 | Notice-Outgoing - Mandate | Notice-Outgoing | Mandate | Final | |
05/26/2009 | Record - Record returned to district court | Record | Record returned to district court | Final | |
05/26/2009 | Notice-Outgoing - Record return letter | Notice-Outgoing | Record return letter | Final | |
05/26/2009 | Event - Case closed | Event | Case closed | Final | |
05/28/2009 | Service - Certified mail signature return card. Record signed for 5/27/09. | Service | Certified mail signature return card | Final |