Log In
judyrecords
search tips
700 million+
United States Court Cases

California Third Appellate District Record

Sierra Club et al. v. County of Tehama et al.

Parties and Attorneys

Sierra Club et al. v. County of Tehama et al.
Case Number C066996
Party Attorney
Sierra Club et al. : Plaintiff and Appellant
Donald B. Mooney
Law Office of Donald B. Mooney
129 C Street, Suite 2
Davis, CA 95616

County of Tehama et al. : Defendant and Respondent
William W. Abbott
Abbott & Kindermann LLP
2100 21st Street
Sacramento, CA 95818

Office of the County Counsel
727 Oak Street
Red Bluff, CA 96080

Contact Name: William James Murphy



Case Summary

Trial Court Case:
CI62008
Court of Appeal Case:
C066996
Supreme Court Case:
S207625
Court of Appeal Opinion:
[ PDF ] [ DOC ]
Caution: For information on when opinions may be cited or relied upon, click here .
Division:
Case Caption:
Sierra Club et al. v. County of Tehama et al.
Case Type:
CV
Filing Date:
12/14/2010
Completion Date:
01/30/2013
Oral Argument Date/Time:
11/20/2012 09:30 AM


Docket (Register of Actions)

Sierra Club et al. v. County of Tehama et al.
Case Number C066996
Date Description Notes
12/29/2010 Notice of appeal lodged/received. Filed in trial court 12/14/10. Denial of petition for writ of mandate.
12/30/2010 Letter to counsel - 10 days to file case information statement. CAMS due: 01/10/11.
12/30/2010 Respondent notified re CAMS. Due 10 days after appellants'.
12/30/2010 Default notice sent-appellant notified per rule 8.100(c). Fee/waiver due: 01/14/11.
01/05/2011 Filed letter from: Appellant advising this appeal involves CEQA.
01/05/2011 Civil case information statement filed.
01/05/2011 Appellant's mediation statement filed. Respondent's CAMS due: 01/18/11.
01/06/2011 Filing fee. Receipt No. R317392
01/18/2011 Respondent's mediation statement filed.
02/09/2011 Case ordered not eligible for mediation. HULL, Acting P.J.
02/10/2011 Received mediation coordinator's letter. Case not selected for mediation.
03/07/2011 Received copy of document filed in trial court. Appellant's designation of the record, electing to proceed by appendix and administrative record without the RT. Filed in the trial court on 02/10/11.
03/22/2011 Motion filed. Appellant's motion to submit an electronic administrative record.
04/11/2011 Order filed. Appellant's motion to submit an electronic administrative record is granted. RAYE, P.J.
04/11/2011 Administrative record received **********. 1 CD (11,491 pgs.)
04/21/2011 Stipulation of extension of time filed: To file AAO to 05/20/11.
05/26/2011 Appellant notified re failure to timely file opening brief. Plaintiff and Appellant: Sierra Club et al.
Attorney: Donald B. Mooney AOB due: 06/10/11.
06/16/2011 Joint appendix filed. 3 Vols. appendix (465 pgs.)
06/16/2011 Appellant's opening brief. Plaintiff and Appellant: Sierra Club et al.
Attorney: Donald B. Mooney Filed per rule 8.25(b)
07/01/2011 Stipulation of extension of time filed:
Respondent's brief. Due on 08/09/2011 By 19 Day(s)
To file RB to 08/09/11.
07/28/2011 Application filed: by respondent to file oversize brief of 28,000 words.Granted to 28,000 words. RAYE, P.J.
08/09/2011 Respondent's brief. Defendant and Respondent: County of Tehama et al.
Attorney: William W. Abbott
Attorney: Office of the County Counsel with certificate of interested entitles/persons (none listed).
08/30/2011 Appellant's reply brief. Plaintiff and Appellant: Sierra Club et al.
Attorney: Donald B. Mooney Filed per rule 8.25(b).
08/30/2011 Case fully briefed.
03/13/2012 Letter sent to: Attorney Abbott; Your "Notice of Unavailabilty of Counsel" is being returned unfiled at the direction of the court as there are no provisions for filing it.
10/09/2012 Oral argument waiver notice sent. Request due: 10/19/12.
10/16/2012 Request for oral argument filed by: appellant.
10/18/2012 Argument order sent. On calendar Tuesday, November 20, 2012, at 9:30 a.m.
Raye, P.J.
11/14/2012 Filed additional cites for oral argument. By respondent.
11/19/2012 Filed additional cites for oral argument. By appellant.
11/20/2012 Cause argued and submitted. Marsha Burch for plaintiffs/appellants; William W. Abbott for defendants/respondents
11/30/2012 Opinion filed. (Signed Unpublished). The judgment is affirmed. Respondents shall recover their costs on appeal. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.278(a)(1)-(2); see also Chaparral Greens v. City of Chula Vista (1996) 50 Cal.App.4th 1134, 1151 [prevailing respondent in CEQA case was entitled to costs].)
12/17/2012 Filed request to publish opinion. By the California State Association of Counties (CSAC) and the League of California Cities (League).
12/20/2012 Order denying publication filed. By the California State Association of Counties (CSAC) and the League of California Cities (League). RAYE, P.J. (Mu)
12/20/2012 Letter sent to: Supreme Court requesting that they deny the request to publish by the California State Association of Counties (CSAC) and the League of California Cities (League).
12/24/2012 Letter sent to: California Building Industry Association et al. returning their request to publish the opinion. The court denied a previous request to publish on 12/20/12.
01/14/2013 Received copy of Supreme Court filing. "Response to Court of Appeal Recommendation to Deny Publication" by Sohagi Law Group.
01/30/2013 Remittitur issued. Respondents to recover costs on appeal.
01/30/2013 Case complete.
02/19/2013 Administrative record returned to superior court. 1 DVD
02/27/2013 Supreme Court order filed re: The request for an order directing publication of the opinion in the above-entitled appeal is denied. Cantil-Sakauye, C.J. (Received 03/01/13.)
03/11/2013 Record shipped to records center - Sacramento. List 56 box 288 loc.# 0366655


Briefs

Sierra Club et al. v. County of Tehama et al.
Case Number C066996
Brief Due Date Date Filed Party and Attorney Notes
Appellant notified re failure to timely file opening brief. 05/26/2011 Plaintiff and Appellant: Sierra Club et al.
Attorney: Donald B. Mooney
AOB due: 06/10/11.
Appellant's opening brief. 06/16/2011 Plaintiff and Appellant: Sierra Club et al.
Attorney: Donald B. Mooney
Filed per rule 8.25(b)
Respondent's brief. 08/09/2011 Defendant and Respondent: County of Tehama et al.
Attorney: William W. Abbott
Attorney: Office of the County Counsel
with certificate of interested entitles/persons (none listed).
Appellant's reply brief. 08/30/2011 Plaintiff and Appellant: Sierra Club et al.
Attorney: Donald B. Mooney
Filed per rule 8.25(b).


Disposition

Sierra Club et al. v. County of Tehama et al.
Case Number C066996
Description:
Affirmed in full
Date:
11/30/2012
Disposition Type:
Final
The judgment is affirmed. Respondents shall recover their costs on appeal. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.278(a)(1)-(2); see also Chaparral Greens v. City of Chula Vista (1996) 50 Cal.App.4th 1134, 1151 [prevailing respondent in CEQA case was entitled to costs].)
Publication Status:
Signed Unpublished
Author:
Murray, Jr., William J.
Participants:
Raye, Vance W. (Concur)
Hull, Jr., Harry E. (Concur)
Case Citation:
none


Trial Court

Sierra Club et al. v. County of Tehama et al.
Case Number C066996
Trial Court Name:
Tehama County Superior Court - Main
County:
Tehama
Trial Court Case Number:
CI62008
Trial Court Judge:
King III, Edward
Trial Court Judgment Date:
10/25/2010