Log In
judyrecords
search tips
700 million+
United States Court Cases

California Second Appellate District Record

Franklin Mint Company et al. v. Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP et al. Division 4

Parties and Attorneys

Franklin Mint Company et al. v. Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP et al.
Division 4
Case Number B190482
Party Attorney
Franklin Mint Company : Plaintiff and Appellant
L. Rachel Helyar
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP
2029 Century Park East
Suite 2400
Los Angeles, CA 90067

Andrew S. Clare
Loeb & Loeb
10100 Santa Monica Blvd.
Suite 2200
Los Angeles, CA 90067-2475

Rex S. Heinke
Akin, Gump, Strauss, Hauer & Feld LLP
2029 Century Park East
Suite 2400
Los Angeles, CA 90067

Lord Simon Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP : Defendant and Respondent
Brad D. Brian
Munger Tolles & Olson
355 South Grand Avenue
35th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071-1560

Frederic D. Cohen
Horvitz & Levy
15760 Ventura Blvd
18th Floor
Encino, CA 91436-3000

Kathleen M. Sullivan
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart Oliver & Hedges, LLP
555 Twin Dolphin Dr.
5th Floor
Redwood City, CA 94065

Mark S. Lee : Defendant and Respondent
Kevin H. Brogan
Hill Farrer & Burrill
300 So. Grand Avenue
37th Floor - One California Plaza
Los Angeles, CA 90071-3147

Roll International Corporation : Plaintiff and Appellant
L. Rachel Helyar
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP
2029 Century Park East
Suite 2400
Los Angeles, CA 90067

Andrew S. Clare
Loeb & Loeb
10100 Santa Monica Blvd.
Suite 2200
Los Angeles, CA 90067-2475

Stewart Resnick : Plaintiff and Appellant
L. Rachel Helyar
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP
2029 Century Park East
Suite 2400
Los Angeles, CA 90067

Andrew S. Clare
Loeb & Loeb
10100 Santa Monica Blvd.
Suite 2200
Los Angeles, CA 90067-2475

Lynda Resnick : Plaintiff and Appellant
L. Rachel Helyar
Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP
2029 Century Park East
Suite 2400
Los Angeles, CA 90067

Andrew S. Clare
Loeb & Loeb
10100 Santa Monica Blvd.
Suite 2200
Los Angeles, CA 90067-2475



Case Summary

Trial Court Case:
BC285388
Court of Appeal Case:
B190482
Supreme Court Case:
S183545
Division:
4
Case Caption:
Franklin Mint Company et al. v. Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP et al.
Case Type:
CV
Filing Date:
04/13/2006
Completion Date:
08/03/2010
Oral Argument Date/Time:
02/19/2010 09:00 AM


Docket (Register of Actions)

Franklin Mint Company et al. v. Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP et al.
Division 4
Case Number B190482
Date Description Notes
04/24/2006 Notice of appeal lodged/received. n/a 4.13.06 Franklin Mint Company et al.5.1 w/RTs
05/04/2006 Civil case information statement filed.
05/23/2006 Notice per rule 5.1 - with reporter's transcript.
06/27/2006 Record on appeal filed. r-21 (3176 pgs)
07/20/2006 Stipulation of extension of time filed to: Attorney: Clare, Andrew S. 9-11-06 to file aob/RB + 75 Party: Franklin Mint CompanyAttorney: Helyar, L. Rachel Party: Franklin Mint Company
09/21/2006 Appellant notified pursuant to rule 17(a)(1).
10/05/2006 Request for judicial notice filed. by appellants, 9 vol. exhbits filed under separate cover.
10/05/2006 Application filed to: by appellant's for leave to file AOB in excess of 14K words (briefsubmitted concurrently)
10/05/2006 Appellant's appendix filed. 3 vol.
10/11/2006 Association of attorneys filed for: Resp. Manatt, Phelps
10/20/2006 Certificate of interested entities or persons filed by: Resp.
10/20/2006 Application filed to: for ext. of time file opposition to request for judicial notice byresp. Manatt, Phelps & Phillips
10/20/2006 Filed joinder of: resp. Mark Lee in unopposed application for ext. of time to fileopposition to request for judicial notice by resp. Manatt, Phelps
10/24/2006 Order filed. granting appellant's application to file an AOB not to exceed 16Kwords.
10/24/2006 Appellant's opening brief. Plaintiff and Appellant: Franklin Mint Company
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar
Plaintiff and Appellant: Roll International Corporation
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar
Plaintiff and Appellant: Stewart Resnick
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar
Plaintiff and Appellant: Lynda Resnick
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar Attorney: Clare, Andrew S. Party: Resnick, LyndaAttorney: Helyar, L. Rachel Party: Resnick, LyndaAttorney: Clare, Andrew S. Party: Resnick, StewartAttorney: Helyar, L. Rachel Party: Resnick, StewartAttorney: Clare, Andrew S. Party: Roll International CorporationAttorney: Helyar, L. Rachel Party: Roll International CorporationAttorney: Clare, Andrew S. Party: Franklin Mint CompanyAttorney: Helyar, L. Rachel Party: Franklin Mint Company
10/25/2006 Order filed. Granting request for extension of time to file opposition toappellant's request for judicial notice until time RB is filed.
12/22/2006 Stipulation of extension of time filed to: ext rbs to 1/20/07Attorney: Cohen, Frederic D. Party: Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP, Lord SimonAttorney: Brian, Brad D. Party: Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP, Lord Simon
01/12/2007 Requested - extension of time Attorney: Cohen, Frederic D. Party: Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP, Lord SimonAttorney: Brian, Brad D. Party: Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP, Lord Simon
01/16/2007 Requested - extension of time Attorney: Brogan, Kevin Party: Lee, Mark
01/16/2007 Granted - extension of time. Attorney: Brogan, Kevin ext. to 2-21-07 Party: Lee, Mark
01/16/2007 Granted - extension of time. Attorney: Cohen, Frederic D. ext. to 2-21-07 NO FURTHER Party: Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP, Lord SimonAttorney: Brian, Brad D. Party: Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP, Lord Simon
02/26/2007 Respondent notified pursuant to rule 8.220(a)(2).
03/12/2007 Application filed to: file rb of resp. Manatt, Phelps in excess 14,000 words (briefattached)
03/12/2007 Received document entitled: 2 vols. appendix by resp. Manatt, Phelps
03/12/2007 Opposition filed. to request for judicial notice by resp. Manatt, Phelps
03/13/2007 Filed joinder of: Resp. Lee in opposition to request for judicial notice filed by resp.Manatt, Phelps
03/15/2007 Returned document for non-conformance. Joinder of resp. lee in rb of Manatt, Phelps pursuant to no brief byManatt, Phelps has been filed.
03/21/2007 Request for judicial notice denied.
03/26/2007 Opposition filed. to resps. application to file rb in excess of word count
03/28/2007 Order filed. Resp's. application for leave to file rb in excess of 14,000 words isgranted. Rb deemed filed this date.
03/28/2007 Respondent's appendix & brief filed. Defendant and Respondent: Lord Simon Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP
Attorney: Frederic D. Cohen Attorney: Cohen, Frederic D. 2 VOLS. Party: Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP, Lord Simon
03/29/2007 Filed joinder of: Resp. Lee in rb of Manatt, Phelps
04/02/2007 Stipulation of extension of time filed to:
Appellant's reply brief. Due on 06/01/2007 By 45 Day(s)
ext arb to 6/1/07Attorney: Clare, Andrew S. Party: Franklin Mint CompanyAttorney: Helyar, L. Rachel Party: Franklin Mint Company
04/06/2007 Motion filed. by respondent to augment the respondent's appendix (corrected pages ofRB submitted and corrected respondent's appendix submittedconcurrently)
04/09/2007 Order filed. granting respondent's motionto augment respondent's appendix.
04/09/2007 Respondent's appendix filed. Augmented. (Volume 2 of 2)
05/07/2007 Stipulation of extension of time filed to:
Appellant's reply brief. Due on 06/18/2007 By 17 Day(s)
Attorney: Clare, Andrew S. 6-16-07 to file arb Party: Franklin Mint CompanyAttorney: Helyar, L. Rachel Party: Franklin Mint Company
06/15/2007 Request for judicial notice filed. Motion for reconsideration of appellant's request for judicialnotice 6 volumes submitted under separate cover
06/15/2007 Received: ARB (pending request to file oversized)
06/19/2007 Application filed to: by appellat for leave to file ARB in excess of 14K words.
07/02/2007 Filed joinder of: resp. Mark Lee in Manatt's opposition to motion for reconsiderationof applts. request for judicial notice.
07/02/2007 Opposition filed. to motion for reconsideration of applt's. request for judicialnotice.
07/06/2007 Reply filed to:
07/12/2007 Order filed. Applts. application to file arb in excess of 14,000 words is granted.Arb is deemed filed this date.
07/12/2007 Appellant's reply brief. Plaintiff and Appellant: Franklin Mint Company
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar Attorney: Clare, Andrew S. Party: Franklin Mint CompanyAttorney: Helyar, L. Rachel Party: Franklin Mint Company
07/12/2007 Case fully briefed.
06/10/2008 Filed letter from: Munger, Tolles & Olson dated 6/5/08 re: request that argument in this matter not be scheduled prior to 11/1/08
06/11/2008 Filed letter from: Akin Gump etc., dated 6/10/08 re: response to letter dated 6/5/08
03/11/2009 Filed letter from: Atty. Lazarus dtd. 3-10-09 re: status of oral argument date.
07/02/2009 Filed letter from: Atty. Helyar dtd. 6-30-09 re: request to remove counsel Edward P. Lazarus from service list.
12/31/2009 Filed letter from: Atty. L. Rachel Helyar dtd. 12-29-09 re:
requesting to add counsel Rex S. Heinke to service list as counsel of record for
applts.
02/16/2010 Filed letter from: Munger Tolles Olson dated 2/12/10 re: cases counsel may refer to at oral argument
02/19/2010 Cause argued and submitted.
02/25/2010 Received letter from: Munger, Tolles & Olson dated 2/25/09 (to court for permission to file)
03/01/2010 Filed letter from: Munger, Tolles and Olson dated 2/25/10 re: ruling by US Patent and Trademark office (with permission of the court)
05/03/2010 Opinion filed. (Signed Published)
06/15/2010 Service copy of petition for review received. S183545
06/15/2010 Record transmitted to Supreme Court. 1x6"
06/17/2010 Received: Association of Counsel, filed by Respondent Manatt Phelps. Munger Tolles and Horvitz & Levy associate Quinn Emanuel, etc.
07/21/2010 Petition for review denied in Supreme Court.
08/03/2010 Remittitur issued.
08/03/2010 Case complete.
08/05/2010 Record returned from Supreme Court. 1x6"
08/18/2010 Record retrieved from archives. Req by Scott Buter from Platinum
09/09/2010 Record returned to archives.
08/13/2013 Shipped to state retention center, box # / list #: 256/15/1034780
08/13/2013 Shipped to state retention center, box # / list #: 257/15/1034781
08/13/2013 Shipped to state retention center, box # / list #: 258/15/1034782


Briefs

Franklin Mint Company et al. v. Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP et al.
Division 4
Case Number B190482
Brief Due Date Date Filed Party and Attorney Notes
Appellant's opening brief. 10/24/2006 Plaintiff and Appellant: Franklin Mint Company
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar

Plaintiff and Appellant: Roll International Corporation
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar

Plaintiff and Appellant: Stewart Resnick
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar

Plaintiff and Appellant: Lynda Resnick
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar
Attorney: Clare, Andrew S.
Party: Resnick, Lynda
Attorney: Helyar, L. Rachel
Party: Resnick, Lynda
Attorney: Clare, Andrew S.
Party: Resnick, Stewart
Attorney: Helyar, L. Rachel
Party: Resnick, Stewart
Attorney: Clare, Andrew S.
Party: Roll International Corporation
Attorney: Helyar, L. Rachel
Party: Roll International Corporation
Attorney: Clare, Andrew S.
Party: Franklin Mint Company
Attorney: Helyar, L. Rachel
Party: Franklin Mint Company
Respondent's appendix & brief filed. 03/28/2007 Defendant and Respondent: Lord Simon Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP
Attorney: Frederic D. Cohen
Attorney: Cohen, Frederic D. 2 VOLS.
Party: Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP, Lord Simon
Appellant's reply brief. 07/12/2007 Plaintiff and Appellant: Franklin Mint Company
Attorney: Andrew S. Clare
Attorney: L. Rachel Helyar
Attorney: Clare, Andrew S.
Party: Franklin Mint Company
Attorney: Helyar, L. Rachel
Party: Franklin Mint Company


Future Scheduled Actions

Franklin Mint Company et al. v. Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP et al.
Division 4
Case Number B190482

No information found.



Disposition

Franklin Mint Company et al. v. Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP et al.
Division 4
Case Number B190482
Description:
Reversed in Full
Date:
05/03/2010
Disposition Type:
Final
Publication Status:
Signed Published
Author:
Willhite, Jr., Thomas Lyle
Participants:
Mosk, Richard M. (Dissent)
Suzukawa, Steven C. (Concur)
Case Citation:
184 ca 4th 313


Trial Court

Franklin Mint Company et al. v. Manatt Phelps & Phillips LLP et al.
Division 4
Case Number B190482
Trial Court Name:
Los Angeles County Superior Court
County:
Los Angeles
Trial Court Case Number:
BC285388
Trial Court Judge:
Trial Court Judgment Date:
03/15/2006