Parties and Attorneys
My G. Tran et al. v. Murray et al.
Case Number D076104
| Party | Attorney |
|---|---|
| My G. Tran : Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent | Gregory Starr Markow CG3, LLP 12750 High Bluff Dr., Ste 250 San Diego, CA 92130 Sean Michael Gaffney CGS3, LLP 12750 High Bluff Dr., Ste. 250 San Diego, CA 92130 |
| Streamline Dental Solutions LLC : Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent | Gregory Starr Markow CG3, LLP 12750 High Bluff Dr., Ste 250 San Diego, CA 92130 |
| Streamline Dental Solutions CA LLC : Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent | Gregory Starr Markow CG3, LLP 12750 High Bluff Dr., Ste 250 San Diego, CA 92130 |
| Tran Murray Dental Corporation, Inc. : Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent | Gregory Starr Markow CG3, LLP 12750 High Bluff Dr., Ste 250 San Diego, CA 92130 |
| Ian Murray : Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant | Daniel Watkins The Watkins Firm APC 9915 Mira Mesa Blvd., Suite 130 San Diego, CA 92131 Beatrice Skye Resendes The Watkins Firm, APC 9915 Mira Mesa Blvd Ste 130 San Diego, CA 92131-7003 |
| Tran Murray Dental Corporation : Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant | Daniel Watkins The Watkins Firm APC 9915 Mira Mesa Blvd., Suite 130 San Diego, CA 92131 Beatrice Skye Resendes The Watkins Firm, APC 9915 Mira Mesa Blvd Ste 130 San Diego, CA 92131-7003 |
| Ian Murray, D.M.D., Inc. : Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant | Daniel Watkins The Watkins Firm APC 9915 Mira Mesa Blvd., Suite 130 San Diego, CA 92131 Beatrice Skye Resendes The Watkins Firm, APC 9915 Mira Mesa Blvd Ste 130 San Diego, CA 92131-7003 |
Case Summary
Trial Court Case:
37-2017-00042515-CU-BC-CTL
Court of Appeal Case:
D076104
Caution: For information on when opinions may be cited or relied upon, click here .
Division:
Case Caption:
My G. Tran et al. v. Murray et al.
Case Type:
CV
Filing Date:
06/11/2019
Completion Date:
12/02/2020
Oral Argument Date/Time:
09/14/2020 01:30 PM
Docket (Register of Actions)
My G. Tran et al. v. Murray et al.
Case Number D076104
| Date | Description | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 07/05/2019 | Notice of appeal lodged/received. | Filed 6/11/19 by Ian Murray, Tran Murray Dental Corporation, Ian Murray, D.M.D., Inc. |
| 07/05/2019 | Appellate package sent. | |
| 07/05/2019 | Notice per rule 8.124 - with reporter's transcript. | 6/21/19 |
| 07/09/2019 | Notice to reporter to prepare transcript. | |
| 07/10/2019 | Civil case information statement filed. | |
| 08/12/2019 | REPORTER'S TRANSCRIPT FILED*** | 8.124 and Reporter's Transcript-2 (21) |
| 09/23/2019 | APPELLANT'S APPENDIX AND OPENING BRIEF FILED. | Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Tran Murray Dental Corporation Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray, D.M.D., Inc. Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes 2 Volumes |
| 10/21/2019 | Stipulation of extension of time filed: | RESPONDENT'S BRIEF. Due on 12/13/2019 By 51 Day(s) |
| 12/13/2019 | RESPONDENT'S BRIEF. | Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: My G. Tran Attorney: Sean Michael Gaffney Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Streamline Dental Solutions LLC Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Streamline Dental Solutions CA LLC Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Tran Murray Dental Corporation, Inc. |
| 12/16/2019 | Oral argument waiver notice sent. | December 26, 2019 |
| 12/16/2019 | Stipulation of extension of time filed: | APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF. Due on 02/21/2020 By 50 Day(s) |
| 12/17/2019 | Request for oral argument filed by: | A/15 |
| 12/18/2019 | Request for oral argument filed by: | R/15 |
| 02/24/2020 | APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF. | Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Tran Murray Dental Corporation Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray, D.M.D., Inc. Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes |
| 02/25/2020 | CASE FULLY BRIEFED. | |
| 07/23/2020 | Letter sent to: | The court would like to provide the parties with the opportunity to address two recent judicial decisions that were not discussed in the parties' briefs pertaining to the first prong of the anti-SLAPP standard: FilmOn.com Inc. v. DoubleVerify Inc. (2019) 7 Cal.5th 133 and Yang v. Tenet Healthcare Inc. (2020) 48 Cal.App.5th 939. The supplemental letter briefs should be filed no later than August 3, 2020, and should be no longer than four pages. |
| 08/03/2020 | Letter brief filed. | Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Tran Murray Dental Corporation Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray, D.M.D., Inc. Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes |
| 08/03/2020 | Letter brief filed. | Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: My G. Tran Attorney: Sean Michael Gaffney Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Streamline Dental Solutions LLC Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Streamline Dental Solutions CA LLC Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Tran Murray Dental Corporation, Inc. |
| 08/03/2020 | CASE FULLY BRIEFED. | |
| 07/30/2020 | **CALENDAR NOTICE SENT** Calendar Date: | Monday, September 14, 2020 @ l:30 pm |
| 09/14/2020 | Cause argued and submitted. | |
| 09/24/2020 | Opinion filed. | (Signed Published) The anti-SLAPP order is reversed. The court shall vacate the order, and enter a new order (1) granting Dr. Tran's motion on the defamation claims set forth in Paragraphs 319 and 335 of Dr. Murray's second amended complaint; (2) striking Paragraphs 319 and 335 from the complaint; and (3) denying Dr. Tran's motion in all other respects. Appellants are entitled to costs on appeal. |
| 09/29/2020 | Received letter from: | Appellant - RE: Typo in the Opinion |
| 10/01/2020 | Received letter from: | Appellant - Add attorney to Published Opinion |
| 10/01/2020 | Order filed. | Appellant's letter dated September 30, 2020, has been received and considered by the Court. Appellant's request to add attorney Francisco A. Loayza-Romero's name to the published opinion filed September 24, 2020 is DENIED. |
| 10/13/2020 | Letter sent to: | All Parties In response to the September 28, 2020 letter from appellant's counsel regarding a typographical error on page 25 of the opinion filed on September 24, 2020, please be advised the court requested that the Reporter of Decisions make the correction. Specifically, the correction on page 25 will be in the following sentence: The emails were sent only to a limited number of persons within Dr. Tran's business entities, and Dr. Tran did not produce any evidence showing any of these individuals had any responsibility for, or authority over, Dr. Tran's Murray's work at TMDC. The Reporter of Decisions advised that the correction will be reflected in the Advance Pamphlet publication. |
| 12/02/2020 | Remittitur issued. | |
| 12/02/2020 | Case complete. |
Briefs
My G. Tran et al. v. Murray et al.
Case Number D076104
| Brief | Due Date | Date Filed | Party and Attorney | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| APPELLANT'S APPENDIX AND OPENING BRIEF FILED. | 09/23/2019 | Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Tran Murray Dental Corporation Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray, D.M.D., Inc. Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes | 2 Volumes | |
| RESPONDENT'S BRIEF. | 12/13/2019 | Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: My G. Tran Attorney: Sean Michael Gaffney Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Streamline Dental Solutions LLC Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Streamline Dental Solutions CA LLC Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Tran Murray Dental Corporation, Inc. | | |
| APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF. | 02/24/2020 | Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Tran Murray Dental Corporation Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray, D.M.D., Inc. Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes | | |
| Letter brief filed. | 08/03/2020 | Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Tran Murray Dental Corporation Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes Defendant, Cross-complainant and Appellant: Ian Murray, D.M.D., Inc. Attorney: Beatrice Skye Resendes | | |
| Letter brief filed. | 08/03/2020 | Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: My G. Tran Attorney: Sean Michael Gaffney Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Streamline Dental Solutions LLC Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Streamline Dental Solutions CA LLC Plaintiff, Cross-defendant and Respondent: Tran Murray Dental Corporation, Inc. | |
Future Scheduled Actions
My G. Tran et al. v. Murray et al.
Case Number D076104
No information found.
Disposition
My G. Tran et al. v. Murray et al.
Case Number D076104
Description:
Affirmed in part and reversed in part
Date:
09/24/2020
Disposition Type:
Final
The anti-SLAPP order is reversed. The court shall vacate the order, and enter a new order (1) granting Dr. Tran's motion on the defamation claims set forth in Paragraphs 319 and 335 of Dr. Murray's second amended complaint; (2) striking Paragraphs 319 and 335 from the complaint; and (3) denying Dr. Tran's motion in all other respects. Appellants are entitled to costs on appeal.
The anti-SLAPP order is reversed. The court shall vacate the order, and enter a new order (1) granting Dr. Tran's motion on the defamation claims set forth in Paragraphs 319 and 335 of Dr. Murray's second amended complaint; (2) striking Paragraphs 319 and 335 from the complaint; and (3) denying Dr. Tran's motion in all other respects. Appellants are entitled to costs on appeal.
Publication Status:
Signed Published
Author:
Haller, Judith L.
Participants:
O'Rourke, Terry B. (Concur)
McConnell, Judith D. (Concur)
McConnell, Judith D. (Concur)
Case Citation:
none
Trial Court
My G. Tran et al. v. Murray et al.
Case Number D076104
Trial Court Name:
San Diego County Superior Court - Main
County:
San Diego
Trial Court Case Number:
37-2017-00042515-CU-BC-CTL
Trial Court Judge:
Trapp, Randa
Trial Court Judgment Date:
05/31/2019