Log In
judyrecords
search tips
700 million+
United States Court Cases

California First Appellate District Record

The People v. Hilliare Division 5

Parties and Attorneys

The People v. Hilliare
Division 5
Case Number A146384
Party Attorney
The People : Plaintiff and Respondent
Office of the Attorney General
455 Golden Gate Avenue - Suite 11000
San Francisco, CA 94102-7004

Contact Name: Catherine Rivlin

Katie Lieberg Stowe
CA Dept of Justice
455 Golden Gate Ave
Ste 11000
San Francisco, CA 94102-7020

John Michael Hilliare : Defendant and Appellant
405 Casa Del Mar Drive
Half Moon Bay, CA 94019
First District Appellate Project
475 Fourteenth Street, Suite 650
Oakland, CA 94612

Brian Curtis McComas
Law Office of B.C. McComas
PMB 1605
77 Van Ness Ave., Ste. 101
San Francisco, CA 94102



Case Summary

Trial Court Case:
SC083554
Court of Appeal Case:
A146384
Court of Appeal Opinion:
[ PDF ] [ DOCX ]
Caution: For information on when opinions may be cited or relied upon, click here .
Division:
5
Case Caption:
The People v. Hilliare
Case Type:
CR
Filing Date:
09/25/2015
Completion Date:
12/20/2018
Oral Argument Date/Time:
10/18/2018 09:00 AM


Docket (Register of Actions)

The People v. Hilliare
Division 5
Case Number A146384
Date Description Notes
10/02/2015 Notice of appeal lodged/received (criminal).
11/02/2015 Record on appeal filed. CT1 - RT2
12/07/2015 Counsel appointment order filed. Brian McComas appointed (assisted; aob 55 days to 2.1.16);
01/25/2016 Requested - extension of time.
Appellant's opening brief. Requested for 03/02/2016 By 30 Day(s)
aob eot from 2.1.16 to 3.2.16;
01/25/2016 Granted - extension of time.
Appellant's opening brief. Due on 03/02/2016 By 30 Day(s)
03/03/2016 Default sent to court appointed counsel. Defendant and Appellant: John Michael Hilliare
Attorney: Brian Curtis McComas
03/30/2016 Appellant's opening brief. Defendant and Appellant: John Michael Hilliare
Attorney: Brian Curtis McComas
04/29/2016 Requested - extension of time.
Respondent's brief. Requested for 05/31/2016 By 32 Day(s)
30 days
05/02/2016 Granted - extension of time.
Respondent's brief. Due on 05/31/2016 By 32 Day(s)
05/26/2016 Requested - extension of time.
Respondent's brief. Requested for 06/30/2016 By 30 Day(s)
05/27/2016 Granted - extension of time.
Respondent's brief. Due on 06/30/2016 By 30 Day(s)
07/01/2016 Respondent notified re failure to file respondent's brief. Plaintiff and Respondent: The People
Attorney: Office of the Attorney General
08/01/2016 Requested - extension of time.
Respondent's brief. Requested for 08/22/2016 By 145 Day(s)
08/02/2016 Granted - extension of time.
Respondent's brief. Due on 08/22/2016 By 145 Day(s)
08/26/2016 Respondent's brief. Plaintiff and Respondent: The People
Attorney: Office of the Attorney General
09/08/2016 Requested - extension of time.
Appellant's reply brief. Requested for 10/14/2016 By 29 Day(s)
09/09/2016 Granted - extension of time.
Appellant's reply brief. Due on 10/14/2016 By 29 Day(s)
10/14/2016 Appellant's reply brief. Defendant and Appellant: John Michael Hilliare
Attorney: Brian Curtis McComas
Attorney: First District Appellate Project
10/17/2016 Case fully briefed.
10/18/2016 Order filed. order filed in A149567:

The petition for writ of habeas corpus will be considered together with the appeal in People v. John Hilliare, A146384. The Attorney General shall file and serve any opposition to the petition on or before October 28, 2016. Petitioner may serve and file a reply within 10 days after the opposition is filed. Briefs may be in letter form.
The court will take judicial notice in this matter of the briefs and record on appeal in case number A146384.
11/18/2016 Record to court for review.
11/18/2016 Case on conference list.
11/18/2016 Oral argument waiver notice sent.
11/23/2016 Request for oral argument filed by: Brian McComas for aplt Hilliare;
07/03/2017 Filed additional cites for oral argument. By attorney Brian McComas for appellant
11/27/2017 Filed additional cites for oral argument. Dated 11/27/2017 by attorney Brian McComas for appellant
07/27/2018 Supreme Court order filed re: transferring case from D4 to D5
07/27/2018 Letter sent to counsel re: Supreme Court's order transferring case from Div. 4 to Div. 5
08/07/2018 Calendar notice sent. Calendar date: September 20, 2018 at 9:00 a.m.
08/16/2018 Request to continue oral arg - to court. from attorney Brian McComas for appellant
08/20/2018 Grant request to continue oral argument. BY THE COURT:

Appellant's request to continue oral argument in the above entitled matter, filed with this court on August 16, 2018, is granted. Oral argument for the above entitled cause, originally scheduled to be heard on this court's September 20, 2018 calendar, is ordered rescheduled, and will instead be heard on the court's October 18, 2018 calendar. Counsel will be notified upon the determination of the exact time oral argument will take place.
09/05/2018 Calendar notice sent. Calendar date: October 18, 2018 at 10:00 a.m.
09/11/2018 Oral argument rescheduled October 18, 2018 at 9:00 a.m.
09/13/2018 Filed letter from: from Supervising DAG Catherine Rivlin for respondent dated Sept. 12, 2018; Deputy AG Katie Stowell will appear for respondent at argument, notifications should still be sent to DAG Catherine Rivlin
10/15/2018 Order filed. This matter is calendared for oral argument on October 18, 2018, at 9:00 a.m. In addition to any other matters that the parties may wish to argue, the court asks that the parties address the following:

(1) Did Hilliare forfeit his argument that reliance on the CLETS information was not objectively reasonable because no attempt was made to learn whether appellant was subject to a probation search condition?

(2) The application, if any, of People v. Williams (1999) 20 Cal.4th 119 and People v. Smith (2002) 95 Cal.App.4th 283.

(3) Does substantial evidence support the court's implied finding that it was objectively reasonable or no more than negligent for Officer Valencia to believe appellant was subject to a probation search condition?

The court is familiar with the issues presented and has determined that each side will be permitted ten (10) minutes for oral argument. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.256(c).)
10/18/2018 Cause argued and submitted.
10/19/2018 Opinion filed. (Signed Unpublished) The judgment is reversed, and the matter is remanded with directions to allow Hilliare to withdraw his no contest plea, reverse the order denying Hilliare's motion to suppress, and enter a new order granting the motion.
12/20/2018 Remittitur issued.
12/20/2018 Case complete.
07/19/2019 Shipped to state retention center, box # / list #: L380


Briefs

The People v. Hilliare
Division 5
Case Number A146384
Brief Due Date Date Filed Party and Attorney Notes
Default sent to court appointed counsel. 03/03/2016 Defendant and Appellant: John Michael Hilliare
Attorney: Brian Curtis McComas

Appellant's opening brief. 03/30/2016 Defendant and Appellant: John Michael Hilliare
Attorney: Brian Curtis McComas

Respondent notified re failure to file respondent's brief. 07/01/2016 Plaintiff and Respondent: The People
Attorney: Office of the Attorney General

Respondent's brief. 08/26/2016 Plaintiff and Respondent: The People
Attorney: Office of the Attorney General

Appellant's reply brief. 10/14/2016 Defendant and Appellant: John Michael Hilliare
Attorney: Brian Curtis McComas
Attorney: First District Appellate Project



Future Scheduled Actions

The People v. Hilliare
Division 5
Case Number A146384

No information found.



Disposition

The People v. Hilliare
Division 5
Case Number A146384
Description:
Reversed & remanded to trial court w/directions
Date:
10/19/2018
Disposition Type:
Final
The judgment is reversed, and the matter is remanded with directions to allow Hilliare to withdraw his no contest plea, reverse the order denying Hilliare's motion to suppress, and enter a new order granting the motion.
Publication Status:
Signed Unpublished
Author:
Bruiniers, Terence L.
Participants:
Jones, Barbara J. R. (Concur)
Needham, Jr., Henry E. (Concur)
Case Citation:
none


Trial Court

The People v. Hilliare
Division 5
Case Number A146384
Trial Court Name:
San Mateo County Superior Court - Main (Redwood City)
County:
San Mateo
Trial Court Case Number:
SC083554
Trial Court Judge:
Davis III, Leland
Trial Court Judgment Date:
09/24/2015