PHOENIX VINTNERS, LLC, d/b/a TRAVELING VINEYARD, a Massachusetts Limited Liability Company, and MICHAELA ROBINSON, a Wyoming resident v. DAN NOBLE, in his official capacity as Director of the Wyoming Department of Revenue, GREG COOK, in his official capacity as Administrator for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, THOMAS MONTOYA, in his official capacity as Chief of Enforcement for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, KELLY HUNT, in his official capacity as Senior Compliance Agent for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, and JASON ALLEN, in his official capacity as Compliance Agent for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division

Case Heading (S-17-0279)
Case Number:	S-17-0279	Case Docketed On:	10/20/2017
Status:	Closed
Original Court:	United States District Court for the District of Wyoming	Case Type:	Original Proceeding - Certified Question - United States District Court, District of Wyoming
Short Title:	PHOENIX VINTNERS, LLC, d/b/a TRAVELING VINEYARD, a Massachusetts Limited Liability Company, and MICHAELA ROBINSON, a Wyoming resident v. DAN NOBLE, in his official capacity as Director of the Wyoming Department of Revenue, GREG COOK, in his official capacity as Administrator for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, THOMAS MONTOYA, in his official capacity as Chief of Enforcement for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, KELLY HUNT, in his official capacity as Senior Compliance Agent for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, and JASON ALLEN, in his official capacity as Compliance Agent for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division
Full Title:	PHOENIX VINTNERS, LLC, d/b/a TRAVELING VINEYARD, a Massachusetts Limited Liability Company, and MICHAELA ROBINSON, a Wyoming resident, Appellants (Plaintiffs), v. DAN NOBLE, in his official capacity as Director of the Wyoming Department of Revenue, GREG COOK, in his official capacity as Administrator for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, THOMAS MONTOYA, in his official capacity as Chief of Enforcement for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, KELLY HUNT, in his official capacity as Senior Compliance Agent for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, and JASON ALLEN, in his official capacity as Compliance Agent for the Wyoming Department of Revenue Liquor Division, Appellees (Defendants).

Docketing Filter View

Display: Chronological Threaded

Docket Information
Filing Date	Document Description	Docket Entry Type	Docket Entry Subtype	Status
10/20/2017	Event - Docketed and indexed	Event	Docketed and indexed	Final
10/20/2017	Fees - Docket fee received	Fees	Docket fee received	Final
10/20/2017	Order Certifying Question of State Law to the Wyoming Supreme Court	Rulings-Other Courts/Agencies	Order certifying question Rule 11	Final
11/07/2017	Notice of Agreement to Answer Certified Question	Order	Certified Question - Accepting questions/briefing	Final
12/22/2017	Brief - Appellant	Brief	Appellant	Final
12/22/2017	Event - Hardcopy received - Brief of Appellants	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
02/05/2018	Brief - Appellee	Brief	Appellee	Final
02/05/2018	Event - Hardcopy received - Brief of Appellee	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
02/07/2018	Order - Oral argument scheduled	Order	Oral argument scheduled	Final
02/13/2018	Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting from Adam Leuschel obo Appellees	Notice-Incoming	Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting	Final
02/15/2018	Brief - Appellant reply	Brief	Appellant reply	Final
02/15/2018	Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting received by Robert C. Jarosh obo appellants	Notice-Incoming	Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting	Final
02/15/2018	Notice-Incoming - Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting received by Shaina A. Case obo appellants	Notice-Incoming	Receipt acknowledgment - oral argument setting	Final
02/15/2018	Event - Hardcopy received - Reply Brief of Appellants	Event	Hardcopy received	Final
03/22/2018	Notice-Internal - Oral argument notice - argued before Chief Justice Burke, Justices Davis, Fox, Kautz and Boomgaarden (Robert C. Jarosh and Shaina A. Case, argument by Mr. Jarosh o/b/o Appellants; Karl D. Anderson and Adam Leuschel, argument by Mr. Leuschel, o/b/o Appellees) and taken under advisement	Notice-Internal	Oral argument notice	Final
08/02/2018	Opinion - Opinion and journal order answering certified question in the affirmative. Chief Justice Burke writing for the court; with Justice Kautz filing a dissenting opinion, in which Justice Davis joins.	Opinion	Opinion and journal order	Final
08/20/2018	Event - Case closed	Event	Case closed	Final