TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF BUSINESS v. TEXAS AIR CONTROL BOARD AND TEXAS WATER COMMISSION - Texas Supreme Court Record

Case: C-9556

Case:

C-9556

Date Filed:

02/21/1990

Case Type:

Probable juris noted

Style:

TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF BUSINESS

v.:

TEXAS AIR CONTROL BOARD AND TEXAS WATER COMMISSION

Appellate Briefs

Date	Event Type	Description	Remarks
04/22/1993	Letter brief	Appellant in case	Texas Association of Business letter br reply to Ape's suppl letter br in support of mo/re
04/16/1993	Letter brief	Appellee in case	upplemental letter brief in support of Mo/Re
03/24/1993	Reply to Response to Motion for Rehearing filed	Appellant in case	Appellant's statement regarding rehearing - will not file mo/re
03/22/1993	Reply to Response to Motion for Rehearing filed	Appellant in case
03/18/1993	Motion for Rehearing	Appellee's motion for rehearing of a cause filed	on behalf of Lone Star Chapter of the Sierra Club
03/17/1993	Motion for Rehearing	Appellee's motion for rehearing of a cause filed	behalf of Texas Air Control Board & Texas Water Commission
02/15/1991	Post submission brief filed	Petitioner	Transcript of Oral Argument
01/29/1991	Amicus Curiae Brief received	Received (instead of filed)	on behalf of TX Trial Lawyers Association, Atty Steven K. Hayes, Busby & Assoc 2109 Bird Creek Terrace, Temple TX 76502, 817/778-4855.
01/21/1991	Appellees' Brief filed	Appellee in case	on behalf of Texas Air Control Board and Texas Water Commission on standing issues
01/21/1991	Appellees' Brief filed	Appellee in case	"BRIEF ON STANDING OF LONE STAR CHAPTER OF THE SIERRA CLUB"
01/21/1991	Letter brief	Appellee in case	Response of League Of Women Voters of Texas to Clerk's Dec 12, 1990 letter Requesting Additional briefing and argument of Texas Assoc. of Business
01/07/1991	Appellant's Brief filed		on issue of standing
07/16/1990	Appellees' Brief filed	Appellee in case	OF TX AIR CONTROL BOARD & TX WATER COMMISSION.
07/16/1990	Appellees' Brief filed	Appellee in case	OF LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS.
07/13/1990	Letter brief	Appellant in case	REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT.
06/01/1990	Appellees' Brief filed	Appellee in case	OF LONE STAR CHAPTER OF THE SIERRA CLUB
05/07/1990	Appellant's Brief filed	Appellant in case
02/21/1990	Direct Appeal filed	Appellant in case	APPELLANT'S BR DUE

Case Events

Date

Event Type

Disposition

Remarks

Document

06/28/1993

Created for Data Conversion -- an event inserted to correspond to the mandate date of a process

CONVERSION EVENT: auto-inserted to match archive mandate date.

06/28/1993

list missing briefs when case is separated(remarks

No Originals of: Ape's m/e/t to file Br. (05-22-90), Ape's m/e/t to file Br. (05-23-90), Ape's Br. (06-01-90), Ant's Addendum (08-01-90)

06/28/1993

list missing briefs when case is separated(remarks

No Originals of: Ant's m/e/t to file Br. (03-16-90), Ant's 2nd m/e/t to file Br. (04-18-90), Ant's Br. (05-07-90), Ant's Ltr. Br. (05-15-90) (cont.)

06/28/1993

Mandate issued

852 SW2d 440

05/05/1993

Motion for Rehearing - Disposed

motion for rehearing overruled. Justice___not sit

CONVERSION EVENT: auto-inserted to match archive disposition info.

05/05/1993

Corrected opinion

CORRECTIVE CC W/MINOR TEXTUAL CHANGES ONLY SENT TO ALL PARTIES & PUBLISHERS

05/05/1993

Motion for Rehearing - Disposed

motion for rehearing overruled. Justice___not sit

BEHALF/LONE STAR CHAPTER OF SIERRA CLUB (J. HIGHTOWER NOT SITTING)

05/05/1993

Motion for Rehearing - Disposed

motion for rehearing overruled. Justice___not sit

BEHALF/TX AIR CONTROL BD & TX WATER COMM'N (J.HIGHTOWER NOT SITTING)

04/22/1993

Letter brief

Texas Association of Business letter br reply to Ape's suppl letter br in support of mo/re

04/16/1993

Letter brief

upplemental letter brief in support of Mo/Re

03/24/1993

Reply to Response to Motion for Rehearing filed

Appellant's statement regarding rehearing - will not file mo/re

03/22/1993

Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion for Rehearing disposed

Filing granted

Mo/Re due 04-18-93

03/22/1993

Reply to Response to Motion for Rehearing filed

03/18/1993

Motion for Extension of Time to File Motion for Rehearing

03/18/1993

Conditional motion for rehearing

No description available.

CONVERSION EVENT: auto-inserted to match archive begin date.

03/18/1993

Motion for Rehearing

on behalf of Lone Star Chapter of the Sierra Club

03/17/1993

Conditional motion for rehearing

No description available.

CONVERSION EVENT: auto-inserted to match archive begin date.

03/17/1993

Motion for Rehearing

behalf of Texas Air Control Board & Texas Water Commission

03/17/1993

Motion for Rehearing forwarded

record remains in clerk's office

03/04/1993

Court approved judgment sent to attorneys of record

JUDGMENT OF TRIAL CT REV/PT & AFF/PT

03/03/1993

Concurring and Dissenting Opinion delivered

BY J.DOGGETT

03/03/1993

Concurring and Dissenting Opinion delivered

BY J.SPECTOR

03/03/1993

Concurring and Dissenting Opinion delivered

BY J.GAMMAGE

03/03/1993

Opinion issued

Court affirms and reverses in part and renders judgment

BY J. CORNYN (J.HIGHTOWER NOT SITTING) 3 SEPARATE CON & DIS OPNS EA BY JJ. DOGGETT, GAMMAGE, AND SPECTOR. 852 SW2d 440

03/03/1993

Opinion issued

Court affirms and reverses in part and renders judgment

BY J. CORNYN (J.HIGHTOWER NOT SITTING) 3 SEPARATE CON & DIS OPNS EA BY JJ. DOGGETT, GAMMAGE, AND SPECTOR. 852 SW2d 440

03/03/1993

Opinion issued

Court affirms and reverses in part and renders judgment

BY J. CORNYN (J.HIGHTOWER NOT SITTING) 3 SEPARATE CON & DIS OPNS EA BY JJ. DOGGETT, GAMMAGE, AND SPECTOR. 852 SW2d 440

03/03/1993

Opinion issued

Court affirms and reverses in part and renders judgment

BY J. CORNYN (J.HIGHTOWER NOT SITTING) 3 SEPARATE CON & DIS OPNS EA BY JJ. DOGGETT, GAMMAGE, AND SPECTOR. 852 SW2d 440

05/29/1992

Phone call from Clerk's Office

Call made to the 250th District Court to request exhibits in case

02/15/1991

Post submission brief filed

Transcript of Oral Argument

02/06/1991

Created for Data Conversion -- an event inserted to correspond to the submission date of a process

CONVERSION EVENT: auto-inserted to match archive submission info.

02/06/1991

Created for Data Conversion -- an event inserted to correspond to the submitted date of a process

CONVERSION EVENT: auto-inserted to match archive submitted date.

02/06/1991

Oral argument

argued for pet by Doug Alexander and James Checkley, Jr. for resp by Nancy N. Lynch and Mary E. Kelly

[ MP3/55.75 MB ]

01/31/1991

Amount of time allotted for oral argument.

25/25 minutes

01/31/1991

Correction filed (See Remarks)

Correction to brief filed on January 21, 1991.

01/29/1991

Amicus Curiae Brief received

on behalf of TX Trial Lawyers Association, Atty Steven K. Hayes, Busby & Assoc 2109 Bird Creek Terrace, Temple TX 76502, 817/778-4855.

01/21/1991

Appellees' Brief filed

on behalf of Texas Air Control Board and Texas Water Commission on standing issues

01/21/1991

Appellees' Brief filed

"BRIEF ON STANDING OF LONE STAR CHAPTER OF THE SIERRA CLUB"

01/21/1991

Letter brief

Response of League Of Women Voters of Texas to Clerk's Dec 12, 1990 letter Requesting Additional briefing and argument of Texas Assoc. of Business

01/16/1991

Supplemental Transcript filed

FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL TRANSCRIPT

01/07/1991

Appellant's Brief filed

on issue of standing

12/12/1990

Direct Appeal disposed

Jurisdiction noted in Direct Appeal.

CONVERSION EVENT: auto-inserted to match archive disposition info.

12/12/1990

Appellant's Brief Due

Addt'l briefing requested due 1/7/91 concern.standing of TAB to br.suit in dist.court under/Declaratory Judgments Act.

12/12/1990

Appellee's Brief Due

Addt'l briefing req. due 1/21/91 concern.standing of TAB to bring suit in dist.ct. under Declaratory Judgments Act.

12/12/1990

Direct Appeal disposed

Jurisdiction noted in Direct Appeal.

BRIEFING SCHEDULE AND ORAL ARGUMENT SET

12/12/1990

Set for Submission

(J.Hightower not sitting)

09/18/1990

No description available.

08/01/1990

Addendum to brief filed

CORRECTIONS TO APPENDICES FILED 7-16

07/16/1990

Appellees' Brief filed

OF LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS.

07/16/1990

Appellees' Brief filed

OF TX AIR CONTROL BOARD & TX WATER COMMISSION.

07/16/1990

Appendix to any instrument

OF TX AIR CONTROL BOARD & TX WATER COMMISSION

07/13/1990

Letter brief

REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT.

06/01/1990

Appellees' Brief filed

OF LONE STAR CHAPTER OF THE SIERRA CLUB

05/25/1990

MET to file reply disposed of

Filing granted

ON BEHALF OF THE LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS

05/24/1990

MET to file reply disposed of

Filing granted

ON BEHALF OF THE STATE OF TEXAS.

05/23/1990

Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed

OF THE LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS

05/22/1990

Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed

OF THE STATE OF TEXAS.

05/15/1990

Letter Filed

LTR FROM ATTY KIDD, ADVISING COURT OF SUBSTITUTION, ATTY DOUGLAS W. ALEXANDER SUBSTITUTING FOR ATTY KIDD.

05/07/1990

Appellant's Brief filed

04/20/1990

Motion for Extension of Time disposed.

Filing granted

04/18/1990

Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed

M/E/T TO FILE ANT'S BR.

03/20/1990

Miscellaneous motion disposed. See Remarks.

Filing granted

M/E/T TO FILE ANT'S BR.

03/16/1990

Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief filed

M/E/T TO FILE ANT'S BR.

02/21/1990

Direct Appeal filed

APPELLANT'S BR DUE

02/21/1990

Statement of facts filed in habeas corpus

Calendars

Set Date	Calendar Type	Reason Set	Remarks
06/28/1993	Case Stored	Case stored.

Parties

Party	PartyType	Representative
TX AIR CONTROL BOARD ET AL.	Appellee	Ms. Linda B. Secord
LEAGUE OF WOMEN VOTERS OF TX	Appellee	Mr. William D. Dugat III Mr. Douglas G. Caroom
TEXAS AIR CONTROL BOARD	Appellee	Ms. Nancy N. Lynch
TEXAS WATER COMMISSION	Appellee	Ms. Nancy N. Lynch Mr. Dan Morales
SIERRA CLUB	Appellee	Ms. Mary E. Kelly Ms. Amy R. Johnson
TEXAS ASSOCIATION OF BUSINESS	Appellant	Mr. Albert R. Axe Jr. Mr. R. Kinnan Golemon Mr. James W. Checkley Jr. Mr. Douglas W. Alexander
STATE OF TEXAS	Appellee	Ms. Nancy N. Lynch

Court of Appeals Information:

COA Case

Disposition

Opinion Cite

COA District

COA Justice

Trial Court Information

Court

250th District Court

County

Travis

Court Judge

Honorable Harley Clark

Court Case

393,120

Reporter

Punishment